Virtual vs In-Office

There are many considerations that go into whether you hire a virtual assistant or an in-office employee. Some considerations include the work you need done, how your office is physically set up, your desire to manage payroll and payroll taxes, what you can afford, and how you communicate best with others.

Work Needed:

Take some time to make a detailed list of what tasks you need your employee to manage for you. If you need their assistance with filing of paperwork, completion of prior authorizations and pre-certifications, and contacting patients with results this can be completed by either someone in the office or virtual. If you are comfortable with the work being done in an asynchronous set up (ie the work can get done at their convenience rather than at hours directed by you) a virtual assistant would be a good option. However, if you need someone to room patients, collect vitals, draw blood, and assist with procedures you will need an in-office assistant. If you prefer the work to be done during specific hours/times, virtual may be an option, but in-person may be better.

Office set-up:

Does your office have space to comfortably have an additional person in there? If you are working in a small 500sqft space, you may not realistically have space for you and an in-person staff member. If you have enough space, do you have any space for them to “get away” for a few minutes? Even something as small as a kitchenette for them to sit in and get away from their desk for a few minutes can make a big difference in their overall happiness at the office.

Payroll Management:

Do you want to manage employee payroll and taxes (unemployment, workman’s comp, etc)? If you hire a virtual staff member you have the choice of paying them as an employee or as a 1099 depending on your expectations and working agreement. However, it is much more complex to pay an in-office employee as a 1099.

Financial Capabilities:

With virtual staff you have the opportunity to hire someone based outside the US. Often, a living wage for virtual assistants outside the US is significantly lower than one based within the US. If you find yourself in the situation of needing help but uncertain if you can support cost of in-office staff, a virtual assistant based outside the US may the perfect solution.

Communication Preferences:

If you are the sort of person who is comfortable with electronic communications virtual staff is a great option. However, if you greatly prefer in-person interactions and conversations, you would likely do better with an in-person staff member.

In summary, when deciding to hire virtual vs in-person support staff, it is important to know what you need, what you want, and how you would best function and hire accordingly. If you know you need help with rooming patients, it would be silly to hire someone to work virtually. In contrast, if you know your office is too small to comfortably have a second person present regularly, it would be silly to hire an in-person staff member (unless you are actively enlarging your space and have real plans and timelines in place).

The content of this page is restricted to active members.

If you are an active member please log in. If you have recently applied for membership, please allow staff 3-5 days to review your application. Otherwise, if you feel you are reaching this by mistake, email hello@dpcalliance.org for assistance.

Virtual vs In-Office

There are many considerations that go into whether you hire a virtual assistant or an in-office employee. Some considerations include the work you need done, how your office is physically set up, your desire to manage payroll and payroll taxes, what you can afford, and how you communicate best with others.

Work Needed:

Take some time to make a detailed list of what tasks you need your employee to manage for you. If you need their assistance with filing of paperwork, completion of prior authorizations and pre-certifications, and contacting patients with results this can be completed by either someone in the office or virtual. If you are comfortable with the work being done in an asynchronous set up (ie the work can get done at their convenience rather than at hours directed by you) a virtual assistant would be a good option. However, if you need someone to room patients, collect vitals, draw blood, and assist with procedures you will need an in-office assistant. If you prefer the work to be done during specific hours/times, virtual may be an option, but in-person may be better.

Office set-up:

Does your office have space to comfortably have an additional person in there? If you are working in a small 500sqft space, you may not realistically have space for you and an in-person staff member. If you have enough space, do you have any space for them to “get away” for a few minutes? Even something as small as a kitchenette for them to sit in and get away from their desk for a few minutes can make a big difference in their overall happiness at the office.

Payroll Management:

Do you want to manage employee payroll and taxes (unemployment, workman’s comp, etc)? If you hire a virtual staff member you have the choice of paying them as an employee or as a 1099 depending on your expectations and working agreement. However, it is much more complex to pay an in-office employee as a 1099.

Financial Capabilities:

With virtual staff you have the opportunity to hire someone based outside the US. Often, a living wage for virtual assistants outside the US is significantly lower than one based within the US. If you find yourself in the situation of needing help but uncertain if you can support cost of in-office staff, a virtual assistant based outside the US may the perfect solution.

Communication Preferences:

If you are the sort of person who is comfortable with electronic communications virtual staff is a great option. However, if you greatly prefer in-person interactions and conversations, you would likely do better with an in-person staff member.

In summary, when deciding to hire virtual vs in-person support staff, it is important to know what you need, what you want, and how you would best function and hire accordingly. If you know you need help with rooming patients, it would be silly to hire someone to work virtually. In contrast, if you know your office is too small to comfortably have a second person present regularly, it would be silly to hire an in-person staff member (unless you are actively enlarging your space and have real plans and timelines in place).

Done Reading? Explore More.

Back to Articles

Take advantage of these great benefits!

Discounts | Insurance | Advocacy
JOIN TODAY
TRUE